What happens if I was supposed to register earlier and didn't?
You owe the back tax, interest, and potentially penalties from when nexus began. A Voluntary Disclosure Agreement (VDA) limits the lookback period to roughly 3 years and typically eliminates penalties — but only if you come forward before the state contacts you. Direct registration without a VDA can expose you to unlimited lookback.
Registering late creates a backlog of uncollected sales tax: the tax you should have collected on sales made since nexus was established. You owe that to the state, plus interest on the unpaid amount, plus potential penalties. The key variable is whether you come forward voluntarily or wait to be discovered.
The standard path forward for late registrants is a Voluntary Disclosure Agreement (VDA): a formal program that limits your liability and typically eliminates penalties in exchange for self-reporting.
What you owe if you’re behind
When you register late, the following amounts become due:
Back tax: The sales tax you failed to collect from customers, calculated on all taxable sales into the state from the date your nexus was established. Because you didn’t collect it from customers at the time of sale, this comes out of your business.
Interest: Accrues from the date each tax payment was due. Interest rates vary by state (typically 5–12% annually) but compound over time. A 3-year backlog at 8% interest adds up.
Penalties: States can assess failure-to-register penalties, failure-to-file penalties, and failure-to-pay penalties. These are often waived or reduced through a VDA.
What a Voluntary Disclosure Agreement (VDA) does
A VDA is a negotiated agreement with the state where you:
- Come forward proactively and disclose your unregistered activity
- Pay back tax and interest for a limited lookback period (typically 3 years)
- Receive penalty abatement in exchange for disclosure and payment
The lookback limit is the critical benefit. Without a VDA, a state can audit going back to the date nexus was established, which could be 5, 7, or 10+ years for an FBA seller. With a VDA, the state typically agrees to limit the assessment to 3 years (some states use 4 years; a few use less).
VDAs are available in virtually all states with a sales tax and are a well-established process. Most states have an anonymous pre-disclosure inquiry process where you or your advisor can assess the exposure before committing to disclosure.
When to use a VDA vs. just registering
Use a VDA if:
- You’ve had nexus in the state for more than 6–12 months
- Your estimated back tax exposure is material (typically $5,000+)
- The state hasn’t contacted you yet, voluntary disclosure only works if you act before the state initiates contact
Registering directly (without a VDA) may be appropriate if:
- You’ve only had nexus for a very short period and the exposure is small
- The state’s statute of limitations has already run on early periods
- You have documentation showing your nexus is more recent than you initially thought
Do not register directly if you have significant backlog exposure. A direct registration signals to the state that you’re now in the system, which can trigger retroactive assessment going back to the date nexus began, with no lookback limit protection.
The process for getting right with a state
Step 1: Quantify the exposure. Pull your historical sales by state. For each state where you had unregistered nexus, calculate total sales and estimate the tax that should have been collected (sales × state + local rate, net of any exempt sales). This is your rough back tax exposure.
Step 2: Identify when nexus began. When did your inventory first arrive in the state? When did you first cross the economic nexus threshold? The earlier date controls your exposure period.
Step 3: Determine whether to use a VDA. If the exposure is material, a VDA is almost always the right move. Most tax advisors recommend this threshold approach: if back tax exceeds $5,000 in any single state, pursue a VDA.
Step 4: Submit the VDA application. Applications can be submitted directly to the state or through the Multistate Tax Commission (MTC), which runs a joint VDA program covering multiple states simultaneously. A tax advisor or your compliance platform can handle this. The process takes 4–8 weeks per state for negotiation and agreement.
Step 5: Pay the agreed amount and register. Once the VDA is approved and settled, register for the permit and begin prospective collection. Your registration will be backdated to reflect your VDA agreement terms.
Common late-registration scenarios
| Scenario | Typical path |
|---|---|
| FBA seller, inventory in 12 states, no registrations | VDA in each state; use MTC joint VDA program to handle multiple states simultaneously |
| 3PL user, 1 warehouse state, 2-year backlog | State-specific VDA |
| Remote employee created nexus 18 months ago | VDA if material exposure; direct registration if small |
| Just crossed economic nexus threshold last month | Register directly, exposure too recent for VDA to matter |
| State sent a nexus questionnaire | VDA window may have closed; consult a tax advisor immediately |
What happens if you wait and get audited
If a state contacts you before you come forward, the voluntary disclosure option is off the table. States typically conduct nexus audits when:
- They receive 1099-K data showing your sales into the state
- A tip or referral triggers a review
- You show up on a national marketplace but don’t appear in the state’s registration database
An audit without a prior VDA means: unlimited lookback, full penalties, full interest, and no negotiating leverage on scope. For most FBA sellers with multi-year nexus gaps, this is a significantly worse outcome than a VDA.
Looking for more answers on this topic?
Browse Registration